Skip to content

Module 2, Section 4

The Financial Disparity Between Renting and Buying

“How do I compare the full long-term costs of renting and buying?”

In this lesson

Follow an illustrative rent-versus-buy comparison that includes mortgage payments, taxes, insurance, and major repairs. Learn how assumptions about rent increases, appreciation, and ownership costs can change the result for your own situation.

Hello again homebuyers, Mathew Enger. Let's get down to the bottom line. If you were to buy a $450,000 home and finance the entire value of the home at 6.75%, your mortgage payment would be $2,919, plus the cost of property taxes and insurance, which would amount to approximately $206 a month and $424 a month, respectively, making your total monthly payment $3,548 a month in the first year. The cost of homeowners insurance and property taxes are currently trending upwards at about 10% a year for insurance and 5% a year for taxes, but this is almost always a result of an increasing valuation of your home. Moreover, different regions of the country experience wildly different tax regimes and insurance complications, so be sure to talk with an expert about your region, and if you are in Colorado, feel free to reach out to me directly so I can give you borderline exact numbers. Be predicting the future cost of insurance premiums and property taxes is impossible, but we can make educated guesses, and that's also the case with home maintenance repairs. You will inevitably encounter various issues requiring repair in your new home, as items like HVAC, plumbing, roof, water heater, and appliances age and deteriorate. Factoring in all of these expenses using our best estimates, your total cost of buying would be $2,092,799. Home maintenance expenses are to be expected, but they are intermittent, unpredictable, and sometimes quite costly. We made some educated guesses in our example. We calculated kitchen or laundry appliance replacement in 2030 costing $1,000, water heater replacement in 2033 and 2050 costing $1,300 each time, furnace and air conditioner replacement in 2039 costing $8,000, and a complete roof replacement in 2044 costing $30,000. Over the course of 30 years, you will have made $2,092,800 in payments, a stark contrast to the $2,400,000 we would have paid if we were renting. Of that $2,092,800 will have gone towards your loan, $164,236 would have gone to real estate taxes and $836,123 in home insurance premiums. We modestly estimated home maintenance costs of $41 ,600 over the 30-year period. So while it seems like signing a one -year contract to rent at $3,000 a month is more affordable compared to $3,548 to buy, the reality is that if you buy the home by 2055, you will have paid a little over $300,000 less on housing and hopefully you will have saved that cash. You will have built $450,000 in equity and you will have profit in the form of long-term capital gains of $642,268. In short, the difference between renting and buying is that if you rent in 30 years, you will have nothing but memories. But if you buy in 30 years, you will have all the same memories, but you will also be a millionaire to the tune of $1,392,268. Moreover, $450,000 is tax-free and a healthy chunk of $642,268 will also be tax-free. There are a myriad of tax benefits to home ownership, which we will discuss in the next few videos. Stay tuned and stay informed. As always, this is Mathew Enger. We are here to help make you a millionaire.

Disclaimer

This lesson is general education only and is not legal, tax, or lending advice. Brokerage services are currently provided by Mathew Enger with HomeSmart Realty; Root Light Realty is a forthcoming brand.